The Night the Grail Fills Guide

Getting BB and the extra classes

There are 13 extra-class Servants. None has a catalyst and none is in the normal draw. Across all players BB has been contracted 244 times, Meltryllis 2 and Passionlip 3 — out of 280,993 lives.

ServantClassContractsGrail win rate
Jeanne d'ArcJeanne d'ArcRuler1,95054.4%
Qin Shi HuangQin Shi HuangRuler1,66571.1%
Amakusa ShirouAmakusa ShirouRuler1,60071.6%
Sherlock HolmesSherlock HolmesRuler1,62453.8%
Edmond DantèsEdmond DantèsAvenger1,13181.0%
Antonio SalieriAntonio SalieriAvenger89667.7%
Hessian LoboHessian LoboAvenger99562.7%
Taira-no-KagekiyoTaira-no-KagekiyoAvenger1,03279.0%
Angra MainyuAngra MainyuAvenger1,06058.6%
Jeanne d'Arc (Alter)Jeanne d'Arc (Alter)Avenger1,23383.0%
BBBBMoon Cancer24486.1%
MeltryllisMeltryllisAlter Ego250.0%
PassionlipPassionlipAlter Ego3100.0%

BB: the full-moon hijack

BB only comes when you summon without a catalyst, the night is a full moon (1 in 8), and the 2.5% hijack fires: 0.3125% per summon, about 1 in 320. With a catalyst placed there is no hijack even under a full moon. In lives with the moon vow the hijack is 5% (0.625%), and with a further condition one hijack in three brings Meltryllis or Passionlip instead.

BB also shows up as an enemy: 12% of wars add a special seat, and on a full-moon night that seat can be BB.

How to earn the moon vow, and the Meltryllis / Passionlip branch

The steps traced from the game's script are in the Grimoire Pass.

Avengers and Rulers: they cut in by leaning

Life choices build up Vengeance and Justice (orphanage origin starts at Vengeance 1, church origin at Justice 1). In a catalyst-free summon an Avenger or Ruler cuts in at the rate below; which class is set by (Vengeance + 0.5) : (Justice + 0.5), and each Servant in that class is equally likely. Even with a catalyst, a leaning of 5+ can shatter it.

Larger of Vengeance / JusticeCut-in without catalystCatalyst shatters
01.5%0%
17.5%0%
213.5%0%
319.5%0%
425.5%0%
531.5%15.75%
637.5%18.75%
849.5%24.75%
1060.0%30.00%

Every choice that raises Vengeance or Justice (age, condition, amount)

The list pulled from every event in the game's script is in the Grimoire Pass.

The Black Grail and Kiara (Beast) crises

A war can turn into one of two crises: the Black Grail or the descent of Kiara Sessyoin. Having an Avenger on either side changes how often they happen. Defeating Kiara feeds into the moon vow that doubles BB's hijack rate.

Crisis rates, collecting all five Karma Phage, and beating Kiara